A Journey of Friendship and Secrets: A Review of Best Kept Secret by Debra Moffitt
When I picked up Best Kept Secret, the second novel in Debra Moffitt’s Pink Locker Society series, I was instantly drawn back to the school days filled with whispers, giggles, and the excitement of best friends banding together against adversity. In the turbulent waters of middle school, where emotions run high and drama often reigns, it resonated deeply with me to see the beloved Pink Locker Society rise from the ashes of their past, and rekindle the spirit of camaraderie that makes it all worthwhile.
In this delightful follow-up to Only Girls Allowed, we find our three protagonists, Jemma, Piper, and Kate, already navigating the rocky terrain of middle school friendships. The Pink Locker Society, which had previously been shut down, is re-emerging—this time from the unsettling confines of the school basement. As I read, I couldn’t help but admire how Moffitt captured the essence of friendship, teamwork, and resilience. The girls’ determination to reclaim their voice amidst gossip and the shadows of jealous classmates reflects a poignant truth: friendship can be both a sanctuary and a battlefield.
Jemma steals the show with her relatable struggles. Her angst when she discovers that Piper, her best friend, has asked Jemma’s crush, Forrest, to the Backwards Dance unfolds the complex layers of young friendships. Here, we see Moffitt skillfully explore themes of betrayal, forgiveness, and self-discovery—factors that many readers, young and old, will find all too familiar. The emotional turbulence is palpable, and I felt a rush of nostalgia reflecting on my own experiences growing up.
Moffitt’s writing style is both engaging and accessible, making Best Kept Secret a perfect fit for its target audience of 8-12 year-olds, while still appealing to their parents. The pace moves swiftly, keeping readers eagerly turning pages, while infused with just the right amount of humor and heart. The overall narrative structure allows for a seamless transition between the moments of excitement and the quieter, introspective scenes.
One of my favorite quotes from the book captures this beautifully: "In the end, secrets woven into friendships can be the threads that bind us—or the knots that pull us apart." This reflection resonates deeply, reminding readers that while secrets can be damaging, they can also lead to growth and understanding when dealt with compassion and honesty.
As Moffitt’s characters navigate their way through emotional highs and lows, readers are bound to reflect on their own relationships. Understanding that it’s resoundingly okay to sometimes feel left out, yet also to find strength in lifting each other up, leaves a lasting impression.
I would highly recommend Best Kept Secret to any young reader grappling with friendship dynamics, self-identity, and the complexities of growing up. It’s a celebration of resilience, friendship, and the indomitable spirit of young girls. For adults who can’t help but reminisce about their own middle school experiences, this book promises not just nostalgia, but also a warm reminder that perseverance triumphs.
Ultimately, this journey through the ups and downs of middle school was more than just an entertaining read for me—it was a gentle nudge to embrace the past and cherish the friendships that shape who we are. So, grab a cozy spot, a warm drink, and get ready to journey alongside Jemma, Piper, and Kate. You won’t regret it!
You can find Best Kept Secret (Pink Locker Society Novels, 2) here >>