Book Review: Comeback by Ella McGhee
As a lifelong fan of figure skating, I was instantly drawn to Comeback, the debut novel by Ella McGhee. Books that intertwine passion with personal growth always resonate with me, and Maxine Chen’s journey on and off the ice struck a profound chord. This heartfelt, #OwnVoices story grabbed my attention, promising a blend of perseverance, friendship, and confronting adversity.
Twelve-year-old Maxine is not just a figure skater; she’s a dreamer, determined to achieve the perfect landing both on the ice and in life. The backdrop of Lake Placid, a sacred portal for all things ice and championship, becomes a character in its own right, enveloping Maxine in both beauty and pressure. I found myself rooting for her as she navigates the choppy waters of adolescence—balancing the expectations from her parents and the bullying she faces at school, all while struggling against a new rival, Hollie. The way McGhee explores themes like race, friendship, and rivalry is both refreshingly honest and relatable.
Maxine’s experiences with bullying, particularly when she faces derogatory remarks about her Chinese heritage, resonated deeply. As a reader, I couldn’t help but reflect on my experiences with bullying and the power of resilience. I particularly appreciated the dimensionality of Maxine’s character; she isn’t just a "perfect" hero. Instead, we see her vulnerability, her bravery, and her thoughtful journey toward understanding that winning isn’t everything. This nuanced portrayal of a young girl forging her identity amidst challenges makes her journey feel deeply personal.
McGhee’s writing style is engaging and light, making this middle-grade read effortlessly enjoyable. The pacing is just right—slow enough to develop the emotional stakes, yet quick enough to maintain excitement as Maxine choreographs her routines. The witty dialogue kept me chuckling, and the skating scenes were vividly described, bringing the sport to life in a way that will resonate especially with young skaters.
One of my favorite passages highlights Maxine’s growing understanding of herself: “It’s not just about the fall; it’s about how we choose to get up.” This simple yet powerful reminder encapsulates the heart of the book. It made me reflect not just on Maxine’s journey but also on my own resilience in the face of difficulties.
I wholeheartedly recommend Comeback to preteen readers and anyone who appreciates stories about confronting personal challenges. It is especially perfect for those navigating the complexities of school, friendships, and identity. The book not only entertains but offers profound insights about love, support, and the strength found within oneself.
Reading Comeback has left me feeling uplifted and inspired. Maxine’s story is a testament to the power of perseverance and friendship, and it reminded me of the importance of support as we all attempt our own comebacks in life. Whether you’re a fan of figure skating or simply love a heartfelt tale, McGhee’s debut will leave you cheering for her young heroine long after the final page.