Book Review: You Were Always Mine by Christine Pride and Jo Piazza
From the moment I heard about "You Were Always Mine," I was captivated—not just by the intriguing synopsis, but also by the promise of a heartfelt exploration of human connection by the talented duo Christine Pride and Jo Piazza. After enjoying their debut, "We Are Not Like Them," I eagerly anticipated how they would tackle complex issues in this sophomore effort. The moment I opened the pages, I was immediately drawn into the lives of Cinnamon and Daisy, two women whose journeys navigate the intricate landscapes of motherhood and trauma in this contemporary fiction gem.
At the heart of the narrative lies Cinnamon Haynes, who has forged a life from the remnants of a troubled past—a good man at her side, a fulfilling role as a career counselor, and a cozy beach home that, though modest, holds her heart. Contrasting sharply is Daisy Dunlap, a nineteen-year-old whose dreams come crashing down when she faces an unplanned pregnancy. What unfolds is a poignant tapestry of unlikely friendship that evolves from shared struggles and secrets, ultimately binding them through the love they both have for a child caught in the fray.
One of the most compelling aspects of "You Were Always Mine" is its fearless approach to difficult themes: race, class, foster care, and the often hidden narratives of motherhood. As I turned each page, I found myself reflecting on my own biases and societal judgments. This book doesn’t shy away from the raw realities of life, invoking both empathy and contemplation. Yet, I did find the pacing a bit slow at times, which occasionally interrupted the momentum of the plot. I longed for deeper exploration into some of the themes—certain subplots felt more like distractions rather than enriching the primary story arc.
The writing, however, remains a highlight. Pride and Piazza excel at crafting dynamic character arcs that feel genuine and relatable. One particular quote resonated deeply with me: "I chose you, but I also chose me, because for once it was my time, my chance to get something I wanted—and you were it." This encapsulates so much of the emotional weight carried by both characters, reminding us that choosing love often means also choosing to care for ourselves.
Despite a few shortcomings in depth and pacing, "You Were Always Mine" stands out as an impactful read. It invites discourse and reflection without losing the heart of its story—a requirement for any great contemporary novel. I would highly recommend this book to readers interested in motherhood narratives, fans of "Hold My Girl," or anyone curious about stories of foster families and adoption.
As I closed the book, I felt not only entertained but also enriched by the complexities of human relationships portrayed within. Pride and Piazza have another solid work that, while not quite the literary gem I’d originally hoped for, still offers profound insights—definitely worth the read for those ready to engage with its themes. I’m excited to see what these authors will bring us next!