Book Review: When Crack Was King: A People’s History of a Misunderstood Era by Donovan X. Ramsey
When I stumbled upon When Crack Was King: A People’s History of a Misunderstood Era by Donovan X. Ramsey, I was hopeful. Here’s an audiobook that promises a deep dive into a critical chapter of American history, filled with poignant personal narratives and a sociopolitical framework. As part of my home library’s Read More in 2024 Challenge (prompt: nonfiction about science), I was ready for a fulfilling exploration—especially one that might illuminate the complexities of drug culture and addiction in my own family. Instead, what I found was a frustrating journey through missed opportunities and lukewarm insights, ultimately earning a mere 1.5 stars from me.
The overall premise was rich with potential. Ramsey zeroes in on what he describes as "second-generation survivors of the crack epidemic," primarily focusing on those born in the late 1970s and 1980s. Growing up amidst the turmoil, these individuals bore witness to the impact of the epidemic on their families and communities. I was intrigued, especially given how their experiences are often overshadowed in broader cultural narratives. Just as I was beginning to find a connection with this micro-generation, however, I realized how Ramsey’s narrow focus limited the book’s scope. Instead of broadening the discussion to include how the shadows of the crack epidemic have reached into the present day, he seemed to suggest a naive narrative that young Gen Xers and elder Millennials had miraculously sidestepped the pitfalls of drug use themselves.
The first chapters were engaging, expertly detailing the lead-up to the crack epidemic and contextualizing its history, including the Civil Rights Movement and its aftermath. Ramsey’s writing shone bright during these sections, showcasing his skills as a historian. Yet, as the book progressed, that light dimmed alarmingly. Sections began to feel disjointed, with somber narratives interrupted by oddly placed anecdotes, like the CIA’s involvement in cocaine trafficking—a point which felt more like an afterthought than a critical analysis.
One of the most disheartening elements was how Ramsey handled the personal stories of his interviewees. Just when intriguing characters like Elgin left you wanting to know their “where are they now,” Ramsey abruptly cut their narratives short, denying readers a meaningful conclusion. It was as if he cared more about fitting in his own biases than allowing these voices to resonate in the present.
What truly struck me was Ramsey’s political analysis—or rather, the lack thereof. His tendency to frame certain drugs more favorably than others contributed to skewed narratives that only perpetuated stigmas. Much was said about the failings of crack users without sufficient acknowledgment of systemic failures in treating addiction. The omission of crucial contemporary contexts, such as the opioid epidemic, was glaring and disappointing. It cast a long shadow over the closing chapters, which rushed through pertinent issues that needed addressing.
Regrettably, Ramsey’s writing faltered in emotional depth, particularly regarding female characters. His treatment of sensitive topics like sex work and assault felt callous at times, an oversight I found difficult to overlook, especially in the current cultural landscape.
In conclusion, When Crack Was King ends up being a disjointed collection rather than a cohesive exploration. For those seeking a deep, nuanced examination of the epidemic’s legacy on modern society or even a thoughtful narrative on drug use, this book falls short. I encourage readers to seek out more compelling works on the same topics—ones that embody the ethics and complexities indicative of such a turbulent history. If anything, this experience has left me longing for a stronger narrative that can truly do justice to the voices and lives affected by the crack epidemic.
So, if you’re in search of a book that reflects on the devastating impacts of drug policies or presents a nuanced discussion on addiction—keep looking. With every disappointing read like this, I’m propelled to uncover something that truly resonates. Here’s to hoping a better narrative comes along soon!
Discover more about When Crack Was King: A People’s History of a Misunderst… on GoodReads >>
