Embracing the Uncomfortable: A Review of What We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Fat by Aubrey Gordon
When I first stumbled upon What We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Fat, I was immediately drawn to the title—it hints at conversations often sidelined, especially in a world obsessed with size. Aubrey Gordon’s voice, both forthright and lovingly candid, pulled me in. I found myself eager to engage with her insights on body positivity, societal perceptions, and the complex tapestry of fatness.
At its core, this book is a confrontation—an unmasking of the disdain often hurled at those who are fat. Gordon pulls no punches, taking a good hard look at the vitriol and hate that surround a fat person’s experience. It’s disheartening, and at times, deeply depressing to read about the systemic issues within the healthcare and food industries that actively work against marginalized bodies. Gordon deftly illustrates how societal perceptions shape our reality, arguing that we must see people as whole individuals, rather than defining them by their size.
The writing style feels intimate and relatable; Gordon’s voice resonates with authenticity. While I appreciated the content, I was left wishing for a more structured narrative. Easier navigation through her insights would have elevated the reading experience, especially in a non-fiction format where clarity can enhance comprehension. That said, I found the book profoundly digestible, despite the heart-wrenching subject matter.
Gordon’s dissection of the health industry struck a chord that felt all too familiar—a world where individuals are often seen as profit margins rather than legitimate patients. This perspective was heavy, but it’s a necessary lens through which to view the ongoing dialogue around fatness. Her acknowledgment that fat individuals aren’t inherently “bad” or “lazy” is a powerful statement, yet I grappled with her apparent dismissal of personal accountability. This tension created an engaging debate in my mind as I wrestled with various perspectives on responsibility and health, both personal and societal.
One of the standout elements of the book is Gordon’s insistence on respect—she implores her readers to see everyone as deserving of dignity, regardless of their size. This resonated with me deeply; her urging for decency is something I hope to carry with me in my interactions.
For the critics out there, I recognize that Gordon’s approach might not resonate with everyone. I found myself lingering on certain uncomfortable truths she presented, particularly surrounding the complexities of obesity and its associated health risks. Yet, I still lean towards the belief that the conversation should include more than one side of the narrative. Her perspective is important, but so is a nuanced understanding of the broader issues at play, especially concerning individual choices.
So, who might find value in this book? What We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Fat is ideal for anyone willing to engage in difficult conversations about body image, societal judgment, and systemic failures. It’s a book that reminds us to question our preconceived notions and confront our biases.
As I reflect on my reading experience, I realize that embracing discomfort can lead to genuine understanding and growth. While I wavered between a two- or three-star rating, I ultimately settled on three—not because I liked it simplistically, but rather because it profoundly impacted the way I view not just fatness, but our collective humanity. If nothing else, Gordon’s book offers a vital framework for compassion and respect, making it a worthy addition to any reading list.
Discover more about What We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Fat on GoodReads >>