Review: The Color of a Lie by Kim Johnson
Sometimes, a book jumps off the shelf and whispers its secrets right to you, and that’s precisely what happened with Kim Johnson’s The Color of a Lie. Set in the tense era just after WWII, it plunges readers into the deep chasms of identity, race, and the haunting nature of passing in a society steeped in prejudice. I was drawn in not just by the historical context, but by the profound questions it raises about belonging and authenticity.
At its heart, the story follows seventeen-year-old Calvin Greene, navigating the complexities of being Black in a predominantly white suburb, Levittown, Pennsylvania. His journey begins as a quest for safety, where he must disguise his true identity behind the veneer of light skin. As he writes, “I felt the mask I’d been wearing take over me.” This striking metaphor serves as a powerful reminder of the dual lives many have to lead, and I felt Calvin’s struggle keenly—caught between the desire for acceptance and the gnawing ache of hiding who he truly is.
Johnson’s writing captivates right from the start, drawing readers into a world where every glance and whispered comment carries weight. Calvin’s inner turmoil is palpable as he grapples with the privileges of passing against the backdrop of the racial injustices faced by his peers. The balance between his longing for safety and his growing relationship with Lily, a fellow Black classmate, made my heart ache. Their connection serves as both a refuge and a reminder of the painful realities lurking around them. “We can be anybody here. Anyone but Black,” he reflects, underscoring the insurmountable barriers of race that society imposes.
The immersive narrative keeps the tension high, though I found myself struggling in the latter part of the book. As the plot thickens and the stakes rise, some of Calvin’s decisions felt implausible, and the resolution, while aiming to deliver hope, left me with lingering questions about the world Johnson so vividly crafted. For a story so rich in tension, it seemed to wrap up a bit too neatly, robbing it of the raw complexity it initially presented.
Yet, amid these critiques, the book certainly delivers moments of brilliance. The haunting resonance of lines like “Not everyone can play white, Calvin. And not everyone would want to if they could,” struck deep within me. Johnson’s depiction of fear, identity, and the cost of acceptance is both poignant and chilling. It serves as a wake-up call to the realities of masking one’s true self in order to survive.
The Color of a Lie is essential reading for anyone interested in the intersections of history and identity, young adult literature, and those who appreciate stories that challenge societal norms. It is a rollercoaster of emotions, presenting a world where the lines between right and wrong are often blurred. Readers seeking to understand the nuances of race, acceptance, and self-identity will find much to ponder in this gripping tale.
Ultimately, while I walked away from the experience feeling a tad unsettled by the conclusion, the journey itself was one that lingered long after I closed the book. This story challenges us to reflect on our personal truths and the lengths we go to in search of safety and belonging. So, if you’re ready to dive deep into the complexities of identity, pick up The Color of a Lie—it’s a vivid reminder that our past shapes who we are, and the truth, as daunting as it can be, is always worth embracing.
Discover more about The Color of a Lie on GoodReads >>