An Abundance of Katherines: A Mixed Bag from John Green
Having had An Abundance of Katherines perched on my desk for two long months—an eternity for a devoted John Green fan—I was eager to dive into this story. After finally tracking down a copy through the shoddy Albuquerque library system, I settled in to see what was in store. However, I must admit the experience was a rollercoaster of mixed feelings that left me somewhat disappointed.
At its heart, An Abundance of Katherines follows Colin Singleton, a teenage prodigy who has been dumped by 19 different girls named Katherine. This quirky premise is classic Green—a nerdy protagonist grappling with love and identity. Yet, as I read, I couldn’t shake the impression that Colin felt more like a collection of quirks than a fully fleshed-out character. Sure, he’s got anagrams up his sleeve, but his emotional depth was lacking as he whined his way through a predictable narrative.
Green’s recognizably witty prose shines through in moments, but let’s be honest: it felt recycled. Colin is reminiscent of Miles (from Looking for Alaska) and Quentin (from Paper Towns), which led me to wonder if this was just another iteration in Green’s catalogue—an emotional echo rather than a fresh story. What used to be a comforting formula now feels a tad formulaic, leaving me yearning for deeper character arcs.
And then there’s Hassan. As Colin’s best friend, he tips the scales as what I can only describe as the "token Arab." His humor often felt forced, and even worse, he played into tired stereotypes. I found myself cringing at the predictable “fat friend” trope, which detracted from what could have been an insightful character nuanced by his own ambitions and complexities.
The pacing was also troubling. Promising a road trip adventure, the narrative quickly pivots to a static setting in Tennessee, robbing the story of the dynamism I craved. Rather than love unfolding in unexpected ways, Colin’s connection with Lindsey felt flat compared to the narrative weight of his past relationships. Even Lindsey—who could have bloomed as a character—felt bland in comparison to the Katherines that haunted Colin.
I often find solace in Green’s heartfelt dialogue, yet the writing sometimes served more as a vehicle for themes surrounding intelligence, love, and the search for self than as genuine emotional depth. While the math and statistics sprinkled throughout captured my interest, they sometimes felt like an unnecessary diversion—more of a showcase for Colin’s intellect rather than an integral aspect of his character.
In the grand scheme of things, I’d say if you’re a die-hard Green fan, go ahead and give it a chance—there are indeed poignant moments and flashes of brilliance scattered throughout. However, for those who crave rich character development and a plot that strays from predictability, I suggest sticking to the flashbacks that weave through the tale, as they hold the heart of Colin’s journey.
Ultimately, An Abundance of Katherines left me reflecting on the importance of character depth and originality in storytelling. While it may resonate with readers who cherish Green’s signature style, I found it to be an underwhelming addition to his oeuvre. Perhaps it’s time to explore beyond the Katherines and dive into other narratives waiting on my shelf!
Discover more about An Abundance of Katherines on GoodReads >>